E-Mail Address: Password:
Forgot password?
Click here to register
[login]
Home Articles Stocks Faq About Us Contact Us RSS Feeds September 3, 2010
SEARCH: 
Energy Tribune Jobs
(click here)
Featured Stories
Guest Opinions
Americas
Europe
Russia
Middle East
China
Australasia
India
Africa
Nuclear
Commentary
Print Issues
Oil and Gas Industry ...
EPA’s Fracking Hyster...
The UN Taxman: Could ...
Asian Energy and How ...
Angola: An emerging o...
Wind Energy Gets Huge...
Anthony Cordesman Bus...
The End of Coal?
Wood to Coal to Oil t...
Death of A Gentleman:...
Wind Energy Gets Huge...
Clean-Energy Forum Le...
Wind Energy’s House o...
PNG and Australia Mee...
Calif. Moves to Set U...

Industrial Agrofuels Have No Future; Does Food?

Posted on Aug. 23, 2007

The E.U. has set absurdly high targets for agrofuels in its transportation fuel mix. By 2020, the E.U. intends to sate 10 percent of its transportation demand with agrofuels, and it is counting on cellulosic ethanol for most of that new fuel.

It won’t work. Advocates claim that cellulosic ethanol has a positive energy return – that is, the magnitude of energy required for biomass production and conversion is smaller than the magnitude of energy displaced by the ethanol produced. And this claim has been carefully crafted to convey the idea that (a) cellulosic ethanol can replace fossil fuels, and that (b) we should be happy with this new technology, because cellulosic ethanol is an energy-positive fuel and therefore, the more we drive the more we save.

This is clearly not the case. The positive energy return proposition assumes that fossil fuels alone are the limiting factor in the production of an agrofuel, and that all other factors are limitless, and therefore irrelevant. In particular, it is assumed that:
1. The Earth provides us with an infinite and instantaneous supply of pure air, fertile soil, and clean, nutrient-rich water.
2. Nature can purify all the water and air we pollute, and regenerate all the soil we erode or otherwise destroy.
3. Mother Earth can feed 7 to 12 billion people, 1 billion cows and all other non-human consumers of plant and animal matter indefinitely.
4. She can also indefinitely feed 1 billion cars and trucks (620 million produced since 1961).

These assumptions were shown to be false by the early 19th century scientists; therefore, a proposition based on them is also false and must be rejected. Interestingly, many 21st century economists still live on an infinite Earth, truly believing that her resources are limitless.

If the positive energy-return proposition is indefensible, what might replace it? A defensible proposition may read like this:
1. Every large ecosystem on Earth must approach a steady state, characterized by zero net ecosystem productivity (NEP, explained below).
2. When humans are not a natural part of an ecosystem (meaning that they subsist, die, and are recycled in it), large-scale biomass harvesting by humans leads to an eventual breakdown of that ecosystem.
3. Remedial actions (waste cleanup, erosion control, and nutrient applications) become necessary to slow down – but never stop – the ecosystem deterioration.
4. These actions require massive inputs of fossil energy and are utterly unsustainable.

From the energy viewpoint, ecosystems are characterized as follows:
1. The amount of carbon dioxide converted by plant photosynthesis into biomass is called gross primary productivity (GPP).
2. The amount of energy plants and animals eat to live is called respiration.
3. The amount of energy in biomass built in one year by the plants is called net primary productivity (NPP). NPP is equal to GPP minus plant respiration.
4. The amount of energy produced in an ecosystem in one year from animals, plants and decomposers is called net ecosystem productivity (NEP). NEP is equal to NPP minus animal respiration.

It turns out that plants eat roughly half of whatever they sequester and animals eat 95 percent of the rest. On average, therefore, the net productivity of established ecosystems oscillates around zero. Consequently, for agriculture, from which we extract biomass each year, we must put in substantial amounts of fossil energy. (Which we do through large inputs of ammonia fertilizer manufactured via the Haber-Bosch process.)

Why is net ecosystem productivity zero? Why is there no biowaste or surplus production in a large established ecosystem that does not receive subsidies from outside?

The fundamental reason for this law of nature comes from physics. Because of gravity, mass cannot leave the Earth – only some heat can. Therefore, all ecosystems on the planet must recycle all mass efficiently and emit only waste heat. Otherwise, chemical wastes would build in these ecosystems and destroy them. Humans have interrupted most natural cycles, and replaced them with irreversible and perpetually declining linear depletion (mining) processes. For example, fields with pastures and cows naturally recycle 85 percent of what cows eat. Move cows to remote feedlots, and we have a huge fertilizer problem in agriculture and a corresponding problem with toxic manure waste in the feedlots. Agrofuels are products of the incredibly fast and harmful environment-mining processes that are by definition unsustainable.

So how much of the global net primary productivity do we consume? According to NASA, in many parts of Asia (India, China, Indonesia, etc.), most of Europe, the eastern United States, and coastal areas of South Africa, we already use 100 to 200 percent of the local NPP. In big cities this number jumps to 40,000 percent, and on average we command about 60 percent of global NPP.

Europeans are finally realizing this fact. Thus the OECD and some European governments have proposed freezing all agrofuel production. They are also reassessing the best ways to reduce CO2 emissions and uncouple agriculture subsidies from agrofuels. Germany, for example, has introduced the most sophisticated science-based government policy on agrofuels and might freeze their purchase. In contrast, the U.S. remains rooted in the settler mentality of the endless frontier.

Sooner or later, the E.U. and the U.S. will wake up to the grim reality of the agrofuel delusion. Let’s hope it doesn’t take too long.

Stumble It!
Share on Facebook   Share on Twitter
Back Home   Back to Top
Related Articles
Germany’s Nuclear Bridge
By Geoffrey Styles 
Sep. 2 2010, 2:52 EST
E85 Case Study: Iowa
By Robert Rapier 
Sep. 1 2010, 2:54 EST
Wind Energy’s House of Cards
By Steve Goreham 
Aug. 31 2010, 2:17 EST
Looking Back to Look Ahead
By Geoffrey Styles  
Aug. 30 2010, 5:33 EST
Wind Energy Gets Huge Subsidies. So Wher...
By Robert Bryce  
Aug. 27 2010, 2:15 EST
Oil and Gas Industry Tax Incentives: Ho...
By Michael J. Economides 
Aug. 25 2010, 7:45 EST
Turkmenistan Warms to US, Hugs China
By Andres Cala 
Aug. 24 2010, 7:03 EST
Anthony Cordesman Busts the Myth of Ener...
By Robert Bryce 
Aug. 23 2010, 6:01 EST
The Great British Solar Scam (and the sc...
By Peter C Glover, ET European correspondent 
Aug. 20 2010, 6:12 EST
The End of Coal?
By Robert Bryce, ET managing editor 
Aug. 19 2010, 6:17 EST
By Executive Order
By Geoffrey Styles, blogger at Energy Outlook 
Aug. 18 2010, 2:10 EST
A Better Ethanol Policy
By Robert Rapier 
Aug. 17 2010, 2:02 EST
CLOSE
MORE
BP Tripled Ad Spending After Spill
By John M. Broder 
Sep. 2 2010, 4:12 EST
Colorado: A Leader in Wind Energy
By Greg Vallin 
Sep. 2 2010, 4:06 EST
Global Jackup Report Card Part II
By Rigzone Staff 
Sep. 2 2010, 4:02 EST
Russian Government Rethinks Energy Polic...
By Anna Sulimina 
Sep. 2 2010, 3:46 EST
Oil Price Ignores Long-Term Supply Worri...
By Angus Mcdowall 
Sep. 2 2010, 1:20 EST
German Military Study Warns of Potential...
By Robert Rapier 
Sep. 2 2010, 1:17 EST
Risks Remain with Gulf Well Cap Coming O...
By CNBC 
Sep. 2 2010, 12:33 EST
A Greener Champagne Bottle
By Liz Alderman 
Sep. 1 2010, 12:44 EST
Obama Lobbied to Add Solar Panels to Whi...
By USA Today 
Sep. 1 2010, 12:39 EST
The Facts About Wind Energy and Emission...
By Michael Goggin 
Sep. 1 2010, 12:07 EST
The Peak Oil Crisis: Prospects for China
By Tom Whipple 
Sep. 1 2010, 11:53 EST
A Nuclear Giant Moves Into Wind
By Matthew L. Wald 
Sep. 1 2010, 11:49 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Oil Sheen Spreading from Gulf Platform E...
By Alan Levin and Julie Schmit 
Sep. 2 2010, 3:58 EST
Oil Rig Explodes in Gulf, 1 Person Injur...
By CBS NEWS 
Sep. 2 2010, 3:57 EST
Canada’s Renewable-Fuel Regulations Comp...
By Alexandre Deslongchamps and Irene Shen 
Sep. 2 2010, 3:57 EST
Petrobras Gains to Two-Week High
By Peter Millard 
Sep. 2 2010, 3:53 EST
Chelsea Produce Market to Receive 2 Mill...
By Beth Daley 
Sep. 2 2010, 1:12 EST
Calif. HOV-Lane Expanded To Include More...
By Viknesh Vijayenthiran 
Sep. 1 2010, 11:05 EST
Chilean President Optimistic About Miner...
By English News 
Sep. 1 2010, 10:57 EST
Strict Rules for Regulators on Ties to t...
By Stephen Power 
Sep. 1 2010, 10:10 EST
Bahamas Drill Ban Hurts Shares in Oil Ex...
By Reuters 
Aug. 31 2010, 1:10 EST
Exelon to Buy Deere’s Wind Power Unit Fo...
By CNBC 
Aug. 31 2010, 12:10 EST
Chile Begins Drilling Mine Rescue Shaft
By BBC News 
Aug. 31 2010, 11:05 EST
BP’s Life on Frontiers of Energy Industr...
By Jane Wardell 
Aug. 30 2010, 1:29 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Europe Crude Markets Strengthen On Deman...
By The Wall Street Journal 
Aug. 27 2010, 11:17 EST
Nuclear Reactor Designs Likely to Win U....
By Kari Lundgren 
Aug. 26 2010, 3:09 EST
Rover Technology Could Improve Solar Pow...
By Sify News 
Aug. 24 2010, 11:30 EST
Romania Aims to Decide on Nuclear Units ...
By Reuters 
Aug. 19 2010, 5:41 EST
Spain’s Renovalia to Invest in Canadian ...
By Shannon Roxborough  
Aug. 12 2010, 2:30 EST
U.K. Will Open Nuclear Power Station in ...
By Robert Hutton and Kari Lundgren 
Aug. 9 2010, 12:43 EST
Ecuador Renegotiates With Foreign Oil Fi...
By Spencer Swartz and Mercedes Alvaro 
Aug. 9 2010, 12:05 EST
North Sea Oil Groups Seek to Speed Devel...
By Mathew Carr  
Aug. 9 2010, 12:01 EST
Fire Put Out at British Nuclear Weapons ...
By the CNN Wire Staff 
Aug. 4 2010, 12:17 EST
Green Activists Out to Prevent BP Oil Dr...
By The London Evening Standard 
Aug. 2 2010, 1:29 EST
EU’s Ethanol Production Up 60 Percent
By Biofuels International 
Jul. 28 2010, 2:29 EST
Britain to Allow Export of Civil Nuclear...
By Nicholas Watt  
Jul. 28 2010, 11:44 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Russia: Iran’s Nuclear Plant to Get Fuel...
By CNBC 
Aug. 13 2010, 5:01 EST
Lawmakers Unlikely to Block US-Russia Ci...
By Washington Examiner 
Aug. 12 2010, 5:13 EST
BP’s Dudley to Meet Top Russian Energy O...
By Katya Golubkova and Jessica Bachman 
Aug. 2 2010, 11:28 EST
Russia to Spend 200M on Largest Wind-Pow...
By RIA Novosti 
Jul. 30 2010, 5:33 EST
Russia`s Zarubezhneft to Drill Cuba Oil ...
By Tehran Times 
Jul. 15 2010, 11:25 EST
Russia Ready to Ship Oil Products to Ira...
By Xinhua News 
Jul. 14 2010, 11:48 EST
Russia, Vietnam Boost Oil Cooperation
By The Moscow Times 
Jul. 12 2010, 12:54 EST
Russia Challenges Middle East on Oil to ...
By Christian Schmollinger 
Jul. 8 2010, 2:41 EST
Russia Becoming Major Oil Supplier to U....
By Ria Novosti 
Jul. 7 2010, 11:42 EST
Russia Holds Oil Output at Record in Jun...
By Anna Shiryaevskaya 
Jul. 2 2010, 11:43 EST
Poland, Germany, Slovakia Delay Green En...
By Catherine Craig and Anna Czajkowska 
Jul. 1 2010, 12:46 EST
Total to Develop Gas Field in Barents Se...
By Geraldine Amiel 
Jun. 29 2010, 1:42 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Middle East Direct Peace Talks Begin in ...
By BBC News 
Sep. 2 2010, 12:41 EST
Qatar Exchange On An Upswing
By The Peninsula 
Sep. 1 2010, 11:46 EST
Iran Sets 2020 Target for Nuclear Fusion...
By Las Vegas Sun 
Sep. 1 2010, 9:55 EST
Iran to Resume Gas Export to Turkey
By Tehran Times 
Aug. 31 2010, 10:55 EST
OPEC Oil Output Declined on Iraqi Pipeli...
By Karyn Peterson and Mark Shenk 
Aug. 31 2010, 10:19 EST
Iran Has No Intention to Make Nuclear Bo...
By English News 
Aug. 30 2010, 12:52 EST
Iraq Oil Flow To Turkey On Hold Since Su...
By Wall Street Journal 
Aug. 30 2010, 11:48 EST
OPEC to Cut Exports, Oil Movements Says
By Arabian Business 
Aug. 27 2010, 11:23 EST
Israeli FM: No Peace Deal Within One Yea...
By English News 
Aug. 26 2010, 11:52 EST
Abu Dhabi To Build 100 MW CSP Plant
By Stephen Lacey 
Aug. 25 2010, 2:06 EST
Iran Test-Fires New Surface-to-Surface M...
By English News 
Aug. 25 2010, 1:57 EST
Iran Inaugurates New Cross-Country Gas P...
By Tehran Times 
Aug. 24 2010, 11:21 EST
CLOSE
MORE
North Korea Hopes for Early Nuclear Talk...
By BBC News 
Aug. 30 2010, 1:09 EST
China, South Africa In Talks On Nuclear ...
By Automated Trader 
Aug. 24 2010, 11:24 EST
Sinopec Says China Oil Imports May Slow ...
By Reuters 
Aug. 24 2010, 11:17 EST
Korea Pension in Talks to Buy U.S. Oil P...
By Seonjin Cha and Saeromi Shin 
Aug. 23 2010, 2:52 EST
China Guangdong Nuclear Signs MOU With V...
By NASDAQ 
Aug. 19 2010, 5:35 EST
China to Send Delegation to Uganda on Oi...
By Emmanuel Gyezaho 
Aug. 19 2010, 12:27 EST
Woodside, Rival Chevron Find More Gas Of...
By San Francisco Chronicle 
Aug. 17 2010, 2:48 EST
Chinese Buyers Defer Prompt Coal Shipmen...
By Steel Guru 
Aug. 16 2010, 5:38 EST
China Asked to Set Ceiling on Coal Outpu...
By iStock Analyst 
Aug. 12 2010, 2:23 EST
Korea Close to Deal for North Sea Oil
By Robin Pagnamenta and Gary Parkinson  
Aug. 12 2010, 2:06 EST
Nuclear Venture to Target Mideast If Exp...
By Ayesha Daya 
Aug. 10 2010, 4:41 EST
Japan May Consider Cutting Oil Imports
By Gulf Times 
Aug. 10 2010, 3:43 EST
CLOSE
MORE
India to Build the World’s Largest Solar...
By Xinhua Net 
Sep. 2 2010, 12:29 EST
Top Envoys to Meet US Over Resumption of...
By Kim Young-jin 
Sep. 1 2010, 11:12 EST
JAL Submits Rehab Plan to Tokyo District...
By Xiong Tong 
Aug. 31 2010, 12:39 EST
North Korean Pair Viewed as Key to Secre...
By Jay Solomon 
Aug. 31 2010, 11:11 EST
Japanese, Korean Firms Eye Indonesia’s E...
By Reuters 
Aug. 30 2010, 1:40 EST
Kingdom, Japan Nearing Nuclear Deal
By Taylor Luck 
Aug. 27 2010, 11:26 EST
Indonesia Approved 15 Oil and Gas Projec...
By Deden Sudrajat 
Aug. 25 2010, 2:01 EST
Kuwait Raises Concerns Over Safety of Ir...
By Elsa Baxter 
Aug. 25 2010, 1:06 EST
The Greening of Mining, Our Place in the...
By Mathaba 
Aug. 20 2010, 2:59 EST
Mongolia Can Undercut Australian Coal Ex...
By Steel Guru 
Aug. 17 2010, 2:09 EST
Bangladesh to Shut Gas Stations Amid Pow...
By Anbarasan Ethirajan 
Aug. 13 2010, 5:05 EST
Chevron Makes Gas Discovery Off Coast of...
By Edward Klump 
Aug. 13 2010, 4:43 EST
CLOSE
MORE
U.S. May Finance Coal Projects in India,...
By Mongabay 
Aug. 27 2010, 4:04 EST
India Overtakes Japan in Demand for Oil
By Aveek Datta 
Aug. 26 2010, 11:24 EST
India Says Still Pursuing Peace Pipeline
By Tehran Times 
Aug. 18 2010, 12:25 EST
Wet Coal Has Hit Power Generation in Ind...
By Steel Guru 
Aug. 10 2010, 4:00 EST
Adani Buys Linc Coal Assets for 2.72 Bil...
By James Fontanella-Khan and Lachlan Colquhoun 
Aug. 3 2010, 5:06 EST
India Interested in Queensland Coal
By Tony Grant-Taylor 
Jul. 13 2010, 4:35 EST
Singh’s Resolve to Rein in Spending Test...
By Bibhudatta Pradhan  
Jul. 5 2010, 11:53 EST
India Auction of Oil, Gas Blocks Fetches...
By AFP 
Jul. 1 2010, 11:21 EST
India’s Crude Oil Production Expands by ...
By Deccan Herald 
Jun. 29 2010, 12:46 EST
Bangladesh Seeks Indian Help for Khulna ...
By SteelGuru 
Jun. 28 2010, 12:17 EST
Scrapping of Fuel Regulation to Boost In...
By Rakteem Katakey 
Jun. 28 2010, 11:51 EST
India Boosts Imports of Colombian Therma...
By Dinakar Sethuraman 
Jun. 18 2010, 12:20 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Nigeria May Give Brazil Access to Oil, G...
By Paul Okolo  
Sep. 1 2010, 9:53 EST
IAEA: Sudan Needs Two Research Nuclear R...
By Bernama 
Aug. 27 2010, 4:47 EST
Solar Energy Brings Power to Rural Afric...
By Catriona Davies 
Aug. 23 2010, 4:55 EST
Wind Could Power 35 Percent of South Afr...
By English News 
Aug. 17 2010, 3:56 EST
Oil Pipeline Sabotage Increasing In Nige...
By RTT News 
Aug. 16 2010, 5:26 EST
Nigerian Govts Accused of Not Favoring A...
By OpeOluwani Akintayo 
Aug. 13 2010, 4:39 EST
OPEC Likely to Maintain Oil Output at Ne...
By Candido Mendes 
Aug. 13 2010, 4:25 EST
Nigeria sees China, U.S. Interest in Oil...
By Reuters 
Jul. 30 2010, 5:11 EST
Shell to Sell 4 Oil Blocks in Niger Delt...
By Chika Amanze-Nwachuku 
Jul. 29 2010, 3:07 EST
HSBC in Energy Trading Alliance with Tot...
By Reuters 
Jul. 23 2010, 12:53 EST
Nigeria’s Oil Company Says Units Won’t B...
By Elisha Bala-Gbogbo 
Jul. 22 2010, 1:51 EST
Kuwait Gives Initial Nod for Oil Border ...
By Reuters  
Jul. 20 2010, 4:38 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Two More Nuclear Reactors to be Built in...
By Nuclear Engineering International 
Jul. 2 2010, 11:57 EST
U.S. Will Object to China, Pakistan Nucl...
By The Washington Post 
Jun. 15 2010, 11:48 EST
China Wants More Dialogue on Iran Nuclea...
By AP 
Jun. 10 2010, 8:59 EST
Iran Reactor Starts Up in August
By Reuters 
May. 20 2010, 11:10 EST
US Calls Iran Nuclear Deal Positive Step
By Xinhua 
May. 18 2010, 11:29 EST
Brazil to Build New Nuclear Reactor
By AFP 
May. 6 2010, 10:31 EST
Iranian Leader Flies Into Nuclear Storm
By Rupert Cornwell 
May. 3 2010, 11:43 EST
Zimbabwe Says No Uranium Deal With Iran
The Vancouver Sun 
Apr. 27 2010, 8:16 EST
Italy, Russia Sign Nuclear Agreement
By People’s Daily 
Apr. 27 2010, 8:13 EST
Australia Will Allow Exports of Uranium ...
By Marion Rae 
Apr. 23 2010, 10:47 EST
Medvedev in Ukraine for Nuke Energy Deal
By Earth Times 
Apr. 21 2010, 11:08 EST
Iran, Security Council Plan Nuclear Talk...
By Farhad Pouladi 
Apr. 19 2010, 2:18 EST
CLOSE
MORE
Japanese Cut BHP Coal Prices
Sep. 2 2010, 5:17 EST
 
Kuwait, Saudi Plans Gas Facilities
Sep. 2 2010, 5:14 EST
 
Turkish Gas Sales Plunge
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
China, Russia Agree to Expansion
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
Qatar to Celebrates Achieving 77M
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
Gas Problem for Norway and Russia
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
Alaska’s Crude Output Drops 4.4 pct
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
China Plans Offshore Oil Expansion
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
Russia Holds Aug. Oil Output
Sep. 2 2010, 1:00 EST
 
PetroChina Discovers High Gas Flow
Sep. 1 2010, 1:03 EST
 
Poisonings Linked To Toxic Chemicals
Sep. 1 2010, 1:00 EST
 
Denver Mint To Coin New Approach
Sep. 1 2010, 1:00 EST
 
CLOSE
MORE
Dow Jones +50.63 +0.49 10,320.10
S&P 500 +9.81 +0.91 1,090.10
NASDAQ +22.39 +1.03 2,199.23
As of 09/02/2010 04:00 PM  
Energy Tribune +0.54 +0.58 92.98
Integrated +0.82 +0.58 142.27
Operations +0.66 +0.59 113.75
Services & Equipment +0.31 +0.23 137.68
Coal +3.17 +0.92 349.33
As of 09/02/2010 04:00 PM  
WH Clean Energy +0.63 +1.58 40.54
WH Progressive Energy +0.67 +0.92 73.60
As of 09/02/2010 04:00 PM  
Japanese Cut BHP Coal Prices
Sep. 2 2010, 5:15 EST
[Read More]
Kuwait, Saudi Plans Gas Facilities
Sep. 2 2010, 5:12 EST
[Read More]
Turkish Gas Sales Plunge
Sep. 2 2010, 5:18 EST
[Read More]
China, Russia Agree to Expansion
Sep. 2 2010, 5:16 EST
[Read More]
Qatar to Celebrates Achieving 77M
Sep. 2 2010, 5:13 EST
[Read More]
Gas Problem for Norway and Russia
Sep. 2 2010, 5:11 EST
[Read More]
Alaska’s Crude Output Drops 4.4 pct
Sep. 2 2010, 5:10 EST
[Read More]
China Plans Offshore Oil Expansion
Sep. 2 2010, 5:09 EST
[Read More]
Russia Holds Aug. Oil Output
Sep. 2 2010, 5:07 EST
[Read More]
[ click here ]
FaceBook  |   Twitter
Home | Subscribe | Articles | Commentary | Stocks | Faq | About Us | Contact Us | Subscribers Only | RSS | All News
Advertise With Us