EU Still Subsidising Coal Industry Despite Climate Change

From Public Service Europe

By Stephen Tindale

The European Investment Bank is greener than it used to be. It now lends half its annual energy pot to energy efficiency and renewables. But it is still lending to coal projects. This is inconsistent with European Union climate policies and must stop now. Some leading politicians, such as British Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne are arguing that, given the continuing economic crisis, we cannot afford to ‘go green’ at the moment. This is a serious mistake. Climate change is not only an environmental problem; it is already causing death and want.

A recent report on vulnerability to the effects of climate change found that climate change is killing nearly 400,000 people worldwide each year. And it is already costing the global economy €930bn each year. The EU’s 2011 Energy Roadmap, a document laying out the union’s aspirations that were backed by all member-states bar Poland, proposes the need for an 80 per cent reduction in carbon emissions by 2050.

New coal-fired power stations would make it impossible to meet this target, since they emit high levels of carbon dioxide – the main greenhouse gas. Taking account of the full life-cycle – including construction and decommissioning – coal plants emit around twice the amount of carbon dioxide per unit of electricity generated as gas plants do, eight times as much nuclear plants and 32 times as much as wind farms.

Since 2007, the EIB has lent a total of €1.88bn to three coal projects in Slovenia, three in Poland, two in Germany and one each in Romania, Italy and Greece. It is true that the EIB does take climate change into account when making investment decisions, to some extent. Its rule is that the new plant has to replace an existing coal or lignite plant and lead to a decrease of at least 20 per cent in emissions, compared to the old plant. It also has to be ‘carbon capture ready‘, so that if carbon capture and storage proves to be effective at scale and affordable, it can be retrofitted to the plant. But that remains a very big ‘if’, and the EU’s failure so far to award any money to a CCS demonstration does not bode well for rapid progress.

Add Comment

By posting your comment, you agree to abide by our Posting rules


© 2013 Energy Tribune

Scroll to top